On August 10th, the 34-year-old singer Lu Han sparked heated discussions online after confronting a critic during a livestream session.
The incident unfolded when a viewer commented, "He looks like he's caked in foundation, such a sissy," during Lu Han's live broadcast. Upon reading this, Lu Han immediately responded with indignation: "I don't even feel like talking, do I need to wear makeup? Please choose your words more carefully, I beg of you."
The public's reaction was divided:
Some believed that Lu Han wasn't wearing any makeup at all and that those who criticized him for being "effeminate" were simply looking for reasons to attack him. Others maintained that "he does come across as somewhat effeminate, influencing many young people negatively, and it's not like he can't be called out on it."
In truth, during this particular livestream, Lu Han did not appear to have applied any makeup; he seemed to have simply put on a hat, without making any other deliberate efforts to groom himself. His naturally fair complexion likely led viewers to assume he had used cosmetics.
Previously, artists like Lu Han and Cai Xukun, often referred to as "internet traffic magnets," were criticized for their androgynous style, which was perceived as weak and feminine, yet still managed to attract a large female fanbase. This resulted in many young men emulating them, leading critics to label it as a "distorted idol culture" promoting an unhealthy aesthetic.
For a period, most top-tier idols and male contestants from talent shows displayed a "feminine" appearance, prompting widespread criticism and even condemnation by official media outlets. These criticisms focused on the lack of masculinity and the excessive pursuit of refinement over strength and resilience.
The National Radio and Television Administration (NRTA) also issued guidelines emphasizing the need to control the performance styles and costumes of actors, explicitly opposing the "sissification" of male artists.
Male artists exhibiting effeminate traits, particularly those with high internet traffic like Lu Han, became targets of public scrutiny. Adding fuel to the fire, Lu Han starred in the poorly received film "The Shanghai Fortress," where his performance was criticized for lacking masculinity, further fueling negative opinions about him.
It seems that even when he didn't wear makeup during this livestream, Lu Han still faced criticism. However, some netizens have pointed out that Lu Han is simply fair-skinned and maintains a masculine demeanor in private life, far from the "sissy" stereotype.
Moreover, it's important to note that there is nothing inherently wrong with men, especially male artists, wearing makeup. Appearance is just one aspect of a person, and everyone has the right to look good. We should not discriminate against someone for choosing to present themselves in a polished manner.
A man who excessively pursues refinement at the expense of his "masculinity," using phrases like "I hate this," "I'm scared," or "Boo-hoo," is truly embodying the "sissification" that critics are concerned about.
